Painting in a round gilt-rimmed frame: a woman in a long black dress, seen from behind, stands at the edge of a pale limestone cliff above a flooded quarry at sunrise, while pink, gold and blue circles and spirals fill the sky, the largest an old clock face with Roman numerals.
Illustration: Ken Pond Creative

Only If the Plane Is on Fire

On the Sunday before Veterans Day 2021, Rev. Cynthia A. Snavely preached about the edges people choose to cross. Her strongest example was a group of young men who refused to fight in World War II, and what they exposed instead.

A few weekends before she preached “To the Edge,” Rev. Cynthia A. Snavely was on an outing with members of her congregation when someone mentioned that a new skydiving school was opening nearby. Snavely said her sister had airborne training. As for herself, the only way she would jump out of an airplane, she said, “is if it were on fire.” Later that day, someone brought up a closed limestone quarry that had been turned into a scuba-diving site. Her sister dives, she said, but not her: “I can barely doggie paddle.” When she told the story from the pulpit on November 7, 2021, at Tri-County Unitarian Universalists in Summerfield, Florida, where she was then the interim minister, the conclusion was plain. “Obviously, my sister has crossed edges I have chosen not to cross.”

Then she named edges she had crossed. When her theology changed and United Methodist ministry no longer fit, she did not give up a calling she loved; she stepped over an edge and became a Unitarian Universalist minister. According to her published biographies, she began her ministry in United Methodist churches in eastern Pennsylvania and moved into Unitarian Universalist ministry in the early 1990s. At forty, unmarried and deeply wanting a child in her life, she stepped over another edge and became the parent of a twelve-year-old. “My sister’s edges and mine are different,” she said. “But we have both stepped over some.” The following May she preached the sermon again, at the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Gainesville. Her full text is printed after this article.

A DARE

The reading that morning was “The Edge Is Where I Want to Be,” by the slam poet Lisa Martinovic, a poem built like a dare. Martinovic, who called herself the “SlamQueen of the Ozarks” before she renamed herself Slaminatrix, performed it at the 1998 National Poetry Slam in Austin and posted a recording on her website in 2009. It opens on someone who just wants to “take the edge off,” and it ends in a cascade of instructions, from quitting a job to getting sober, that finishes with “run, don’t walk, to the edge.” Snavely didn’t pretend the whole list fit everyone. “Not every line applies to all of us,” she said. “But likely one or two apply to each of us.”

THE EDGE OF REFUSAL

The service fell on the Sunday before Veterans Day, and Snavely had asked members for pictures and short write-ups for a salute to veterans. Her own family supplied examples of commitment. Her sister finished high school at seventeen, needed to be eighteen to train in Military Intelligence and had to lose weight to qualify, so she worked short-term jobs and took up running until she could join the Army. Her nephew, born deaf in one ear, was a sophomore at The Citadel with a Navy contract and hoped to work on nuclear submarines.

One member answered her request with a reminder of another form of service: conscientious objection. “Some people choose not to serve in the military,” Snavely said, “on purpose, and at great cost. Their edge is different.” To show how different, she told a story from the Second World War.

THE LAST STOP ON THE BUS

The story came from a 2009 report by Joseph Shapiro for NPR’s All Things Considered. During the war, more than 40,000 American men refused to fight, and about 3,000 of them were assigned to work in 62 state mental hospitals. One was the Philadelphia State Hospital, known as Byberry, which held more than 6,000 patients. Warren Sawyer, a young Quaker, reported there in September 1942. “Byberry’s the last stop on the bus,” he told Shapiro, and the other riders let the objectors know what they thought of them. Sawyer remembered the words: “Yellowbellies, slackers.”

Inside, it was worse. Sawyer told NPR of three men looking after 350 incontinent patients. Regular attendants beat patients with sawed-off broom handles and a rubber hose filled with buckshot. The objectors were horrified, Snavely said, “not only by neglect, but by brutality,” and they worried that kindness was not enough: when the war ended they would leave, and the suffering would stay. So they set out to expose the place. Sawyer wrote home about “a carefully laid out plan to blow this place open.”

They gathered evidence. Charlie Lord, another objector, hid a small Agfa camera in his jacket pocket and shot three rolls of film. “If the photograph is there,” he told NPR, “you can’t deny it.” Eleanor Roosevelt saw the pictures in September 1945. In May 1946, Life published them in Albert Q. Maisel’s exposé “Bedlam 1946,” according to the National Park Service, and Pennsylvania’s governor and welfare secretary disputed it.

The objectors’ work outlasted the war. A documentation program they started at Byberry in 1944 became the National Mental Health Foundation in 1946, and through a 1950 merger it became part of the organization now called Mental Health America. “Their edge was not combat,” Snavely said. “It was exposure, risk, and truth.”

When Snavely told their story, one of them was still alive. Warren Sawyer was 101. He had spent 46 years in real estate in New Jersey, and he told NPR that he was proudest of helping to integrate neighborhoods. He died in November 2023, at 103, according to Friends Journal. Charlie Lord died in January 2010, a month after NPR aired his story. Byberry closed in 1990, and almost all of its buildings were torn down in 2006.

TAKING THE EDGE OFF

Snavely spent the rest of the sermon on how people avoid the edge. Martinovic’s poem opens with the small ways people dull it, and Snavely supplied her own list: “Ice cream. A drink. A distraction.” They may dull the edge, she said, “but they may also keep us from crossing it.”

She knew because she had tried. In the United Methodist Church of those years, clergy were ordained first as deacons and later as elders, a two-step system the church ended in 1996. At her examination for deacon’s orders, one man on the board grilled her about infant baptism. She knew the answer he wanted, but her tradition allowed families to choose, and she would not give it to him. He asked again, and again. She failed. Back in her seminary dorm, she found that her Girl Scout cookies had arrived, and she ate three-quarters of the box in one sitting. “All I got was a sugar headache and a stomachache,” she said. What moved her toward the edge she needed was slower: another year of growth, determination, and remembering that this was not the end.

The edge, as Martinovic wrote and Snavely read, is not supposed to be comfortable. It is change, “what you don’t see coming.” Snavely did not promise otherwise. She asked what kind of life her listeners wanted, one with no risk, no challenge and no triumph. Then, before the closing prayer, the minister who would jump out of an airplane only if it were on fire gave her congregation three instructions. “Step up to it,” she said. “Step over it. And fly.”

The short version

  • On November 7, 2021, the Sunday before Veterans Day, Rev. Cynthia A. Snavely preached “To the Edge” at Tri-County Unitarian Universalists in Summerfield, Florida: a sermon about the edges people choose to cross, built around Lisa Martinovic’s slam poem “The Edge Is Where I Want to Be.”
  • Her strongest example was the World War II conscientious objectors at Byberry, a Philadelphia state mental hospital, who secretly documented its abuses. Their photographs ran in Life in 1946, and the program they started led to today’s Mental Health America.
  • Her warning: the things we use to take the edge off, like ice cream, a drink or a distraction, can also keep us from crossing it.
Back to the top ↑

Sources: the sermon text (below); Joseph Shapiro, “WWII Pacifists Exposed Mental Ward Horrors,” NPR, December 30, 2009; the National Park Service; the Civilian Public Service archive; Friends Journal; the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia; UM News; slaminatrix.com. Disclosure: Ken W. Pond is the webmaster of Tri-County Unitarian Universalists, whose current minister, Rev. Kristina Spaude, is his partner.

THE SERMON

The full text of Rev. Cynthia A. Snavely’s sermon, preached at Tri-County Unitarian Universalists on November 7, 2021.

To the Edge

Sunday, November 7, 2021
Tri-County Unitarian Universalist · Summerfield, Florida
Rev. Cynthia A. Snavely

Reading: “The Edge Is Where I Want to Be” — Lisa Martinovic
The Edge Is Where I Want to Be | Slaminatrix

Different Edges, Same Courage

I was on an outing with some of you a few weekends ago when someone mentioned that a new skydiving school was opening nearby. I responded that my sister has airborne training—but the only way I would jump out of an airplane is if it were on fire.

Later on that same outing, someone mentioned that a closed limestone quarry had been repurposed as a scuba-diving venue. Again, I said my sister scuba dives, but that is not for me. I can barely doggie paddle.

Obviously, my sister has crossed edges I have chosen not to cross.

But—when my theology changed and United Methodist ministry no longer fit, I did not give up a calling I loved. I stepped over an edge and became a Unitarian Universalist minister.

When I turned forty, was unmarried, and deeply wanted a child in my life, I stepped over another edge and became the parent of a twelve-year-old.

My sister’s edges and mine are different.
But we have both stepped over some.

A Dare from the Poem

Lisa Martinovic ends her poem with a cascade of invitations:

“quit your job
quit smoking
quit whining
leave that jerk
write that poem
go dancing
get sober
take a road trip”

A dare.
A spin.
A lover.
A chance.

“honey, break down and cry if that’s what it takes
then pick your ass up and for all you’re worth
run, don’t walk, to the edge.”

Not every line applies to all of us.
But likely one or two apply to each of us.

Choosing the Edge on Purpose

My sister had to be determined to join the Army. With a December birthday, she was just seventeen when she graduated high school and needed to be eighteen to train in Military Intelligence. She also had to lose weight to meet requirements.

She worked short-term jobs. She took up running.
She wanted that edge.

Now my nephew dreams of joining the Navy, working on nuclear submarines. He was born deaf in one ear—but he did not give up. Today he is a sophomore at The Citadel and has received a Navy contract. The rest of college is paid for, and then the Navy will have him.

Different edges.
Deep commitment.

The Edge of Refusal

When I asked you for pictures and blurbs for today’s veterans’ salute, one of you reminded me of another form of service: conscientious objection.

Some people choose not to serve in the military—on purpose, and at great cost.

Their edge is different.

A Dangerous Edge at Byberry

In 2009, journalist Joseph Shapiro reported for All Things Considered about World War II conscientious objectors.

In September 1942, Warren Sawyer, a twenty-three-year-old Quaker pacifist, reported for volunteer service at a state mental hospital—Philadelphia State Hospital, known as Byberry.

“Byberry’s the last stop on the bus,” Sawyer recalled.
“People would mutter ‘yellowbellies’ and ‘slackers,’ hoping we’d hear.”

Inside the gates, conditions were far worse.

The pacifists were horrified—not only by neglect, but by brutality.

They worried that kindness alone was not enough. When the war ended, they would leave—but the suffering would remain.

So they stepped over another edge.

“We are working on a carefully laid-out plan to blow this place open,” Sawyer wrote.

In secret, they gathered evidence and went to the newspapers.

Shapiro later reported:

“Conscientious objectors from Byberry helped professionalize state hospital care and dramatically improve the lives of vulnerable people.”

Their edge was not combat.
It was exposure, risk, and truth.

Why We Avoid the Edge

Sometimes it takes effort just to screw up the courage to approach it.

Martinovic begins her poem this way:

“so you just want to take the edge off
one beer
one joint
one teeny-weeny Prozac”

She asks:

“get rid of the edge?”

And answers:

“the edge holds the answer to your questions
the question to your answers
it’s the trailhead to the road not taken
the edge is everywhere you’ve never dared to be.”

Ice cream. A drink. A distraction.
They may dull the edge—but they may also keep us from crossing it.

A Missed Edge (and Some Cookies)

In the United Methodist Church, ordination happens in stages: first deacon, then elder.

When I went before the board examining me for deacon’s orders, one man grilled me on infant baptism. I knew the answer he wanted—but my own tradition allowed families to choose.

I would not give him his answer.
He asked again.
And again.

I failed.

When I returned to my seminary dorm, my Girl Scout cookies had arrived. I ate three-quarters of the box in one sitting.

All I got was a sugar headache and a stomachache.

Cookies did not move me closer to the edge I needed.

What did?
Another year of growth.
Determination.
And remembering this was not the end.

What the Edge Feels Like

Martinovic writes:

“there are no disguises here on the edge
everyone is naked
all bets are off”

“your heart’s pounding
you’re shaking
you’re lightheaded and queasy”

“damn right it’s uncomfortable
the edge is change
it’s what you don’t see coming”

Living at the edge is not easy.

It is terrifying.

But ask yourself:
What kind of life do you want?

No risk?
No challenge?
No triumph?

Don’t Take the Edge Off

Don’t numb it.
Don’t dull it.

Step up to it.
Step over it.
And fly.

A Prayer for Courage

Let us pray with words by Jean Olson:

May you be brave enough to expose your aching woundedness
and reveal your vulnerability.

May you speak your deepest truths,
knowing they will change as you do.

May you sing the music within you,
playing your song with all your heart.

May you love, even when your heart breaks again and again.

And until the end of your days,
may your life be filled with possibilities and courage.

Amen.

Back to the top ↑