
The Subtle Art of Being Uncool
We tell the story of every argument the same way: they lost it, and I stayed cool. Why we perform calm, what it costs us, and why it's all right to be uncool.
Read by Charlie, an AI voice.
I have three sisters. Once, on purpose, I asked each of them, separately, to tell me the same story. In each version, the aggressor was someone else, and the account of how it happened was exaggerated, or invented outright. After that, I started noticing other people’s stories, and how they all contain the same lining of editorial.
You’ve heard it. Someone tells you about a run-in at work or a scene at the store, and it comes out the same way every time: “That person today, they got so very emotional.” Then the verdict, in some form: “That situation was crazy. I wasn’t crazy. I was cool.”
It’s a strange paradox. We like to present ourselves as emotional creatures, people with empathy, loyalty and passion. But when there’s a conflict, we want to be the first one to say, “Oh, hey! Wait! Calm down!”
Emotions are energy, and I sometimes think of them as fire. Fire is volatile. It grows. It can amplify itself between two people. Yet whoever tells the story afterward always seems to have walked out of the fire untouched.
THE STORY IS THE TELL
The irony is in the telling. The person who says “I don’t care, it didn’t affect me” says it to a coworker at lunch, then to a spouse at dinner, then to a friend on the phone. They’re thinking about it all day, enough to keep saying it out loud. It affected them. It affects all of us.
Psychologists have measured this. Bernard Rimé, who has spent decades studying what he calls the social sharing of emotion, sums up his lab’s findings this way: people talk over 80 to 95 percent of their emotional experiences with someone else. The more an experience shakes us, the more we talk about it, and the more people hear it.
The stories travel, too. In one study, college students visited a hospital morgue. The students who reacted most strongly told the most people, and the effect carried on: their friends told more people too, and so did their friends’ friends. Within ten days, nearly 900 people had heard about the visit.
So the story is the tell. Telling the same story five times before dinner is a pretty good sign it got to you.
The reverse doesn’t hold, and it’s worth saying. Keeping quiet doesn’t prove anyone is calm. In another study, the experiences people kept secret were every bit as intense as the ones they shared. They just carried more shame.
“I DON’T CARE WHAT ANYBODY THINKS”
In my experience, the people who deny all this are often the ones struggling with it most. One of my favorite things people do is say, out loud, mind you, “I don’t care what anybody thinks.” Nobody announces that they don’t care what anybody thinks without caring first. To make the statement at all, you have to care, and then decide not to.
The psychologist Mark Leary tested people who say it. In two experiments, strangers in a lab gave people approval or disapproval, and Leary’s team measured what it did to their self-esteem. It clearly affected self-esteem, including that of the people who had said other people’s opinions didn’t affect them. “People underestimate the degree to which they are influenced by others,” Leary said when the study came out in 2003.
We are social animals. Leary’s explanation is that self-esteem works like a gauge, one that “monitors others’ reactions and alerts the individual to the possibility of social exclusion.” Saying the gauge is off doesn’t switch it off.
ALL OF US ARE EMPATHS
There’s a lot of talk about empaths, people who are supposedly more vulnerable than the rest of us to the emotional energy of those around them. I believe that’s nonsense. All of us are empaths.
The word itself came from science fiction. It first appeared in a 1956 story by J. T. McIntosh called “The Empath,” and a 1968 Star Trek episode of the same name helped spread it. Self-help writers turned it into a personality type in the 2000s. “Everyone has empathy, to a degree, even psychopaths,” the neuroscientist Dean Burnett told BBC Science Focus.
It starts early. In one study, newborns showed more distress, for longer, at the sound of another newborn crying than at a recording of their own cry. And when researchers measure empathy in adults, they find a sliding scale, not two kinds of people.
All of us are both spiritual beings and animals. I believe we’re tuned in to one another’s emotions, biologically and spiritually, because we have to be: to relate to one another and, fundamentally, to survive. So when someone loses their cool, even over something minor, even because they’re having a bad day, it gets into the people around them. That isn’t a weakness. It’s what we’re built to do.
WHAT PLAYING COOL COSTS
When we say we stayed out of it, what we usually mean is that we hid it. Hiding isn’t the same as not feeling. In a 1993 study, the psychologists James Gross and Robert Levenson showed people a disgusting film and asked some of them to behave “in such a way that a person watching you would not know you were feeling anything.” On the outside, they managed it: their faces showed less. But they felt just as much disgust, and their bodies showed more of the fight-or-flight response, not less.
It costs the other person, too. In another study, pairs of women who had just met discussed an upsetting topic, and one woman in each pair was asked to hide her feelings. The conversations went worse. Rapport dropped, and blood pressure rose, both in the woman hiding her feelings and in the partner who hadn’t been asked to hide anything.
Think about that the next time someone stays icily calm through an argument. The calm one may be the one raising the room’s blood pressure.
THE CURATED CALM
We’ve built a whole public life on this. Look at what we post: our pets, our families, our husbands and wives, our anniversaries, our celebrations. And alongside them, the message that we’re well-tuned people when it comes to emotional equanimity. The car payments are under control. The mortgage is well in hand. Everything is fine, and because everything is fine, we can project a florid facade of coolness, of calm, of lucidity. The human condition is more tumultuous than that. It’s erratic.
The hiding has a cost you can measure. In a 2011 paper, Alexander Jordan and his colleagues found that people underestimate how often their peers feel bad and overestimate how often they feel good, partly because those peers keep their bad feelings to themselves. The more people underestimated their peers’ misery, the lonelier and less satisfied with life they tended to be. The paper’s title says it plainly: “Misery Has More Company Than People Think.”
That research was about people’s real-life peers, not their feeds, and I suspect a feed only makes the hiding easier. In a survey of college students, the heavier Facebook users were more likely to agree that other people were happier and had better lives.
WHY WE WATCH
And then there are the videos: a stranger losing it in a checkout line, at an airline gate, in a parking lot. The internet files many of them under “Karen,” a name that began as Black commentary on white women policing Black people in public, and has since spread to almost any woman filmed losing her temper. By April 2020, TikTok videos about the meme had more than 816 million views.
We like to think we don’t identify with the people in those videos. I think we watch because they’re showing us things we’ve all felt: entitlement, or anger, or a bad day stacked on top of some other nonsense in our lives. We’ve all had the impulse to rage.
The closest research, on online shaming, points to less flattering motives: the sense that the person deserves it, plain schadenfreude, and, for some of the people surveyed, entertainment. I don’t think that contradicts me. You can only enjoy watching someone lose it if you know what losing it feels like.
And the fire spreads faster online. “If moral outrage is a fire, the internet is like gasoline,” the Yale psychologist Molly Crockett said in 2017. In a 2017 study of more than half a million tweets, each additional word that was both moral and emotional raised retweets by about 20 percent.
WHERE COOL CAME FROM
None of this makes cool worthless. The word has a better history than the way we use it. The historian Joel Dinerstein credits the jazz saxophonist Lester Young as “the first to say ‘I’m cool’ in reference to a state of mind.” For Young, a Black musician in the 1930s and ’40s, it meant keeping yourself together, in mind and spirit, against oppressive social forces.
That kind of cool is real, and it has a purpose. We play cool because we need to be political. We need to lubricate our journey with and through the other people in our lives. I’m not against the performance. I’m against believing it, and against telling the story afterward as if the other person were the only one who felt anything.
Being uncool isn’t a license to rage, either. A 2017 review of 43 studies found that hiding emotions went with worse first impressions and weaker relationships, and that openly expressing anger carried social costs of its own. The point isn’t to blow up. It’s to stop pretending you didn’t feel anything.
I still think about my sisters’ three versions of one story, each shaped so that someone else was the aggressor. The shaping is the giveaway, and it’s in everyone’s stories once you start listening for it. People don’t take that much care with a story that didn’t matter to them.
We are not cool. We play cool, and sometimes we have to. It’s okay that things aren’t always cool. The hard part is being okay with it.
The short version
- We tell the story of a conflict the same way: they lost it, and I stayed cool. But retelling it all day is the sign it got to us. Research on how people share emotional experiences finds that the ones that shake us most get told most.
- Hiding a feeling isn’t the same as not having it. In lab studies, people who masked their emotions felt them just as much, and their conversation partners’ blood pressure rose.
- Cool began as composure under pressure, and it still has its uses. Uncool isn’t a license to rage. It’s okay that things aren’t always cool; the hard part is being okay with it.
Sources: Bernard Rimé, “Emotion Elicits the Social Sharing of Emotion,” Emotion Review, 2009, and his chapter in Personality, Human Development, and Culture, 2010; Harber and Cohen, Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 2005; Finkenauer and Rimé, Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 1998; Leary et al., Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2003, and Wake Forest University, May 27, 2003; Leary et al., Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1995; Dictionary.com, “empath”; BBC Science Focus, May 5, 2023; Dondi, Simion and Caltran, Developmental Psychology, 1999; Baron-Cohen and Wheelwright, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 2004; Lionetti et al., Translational Psychiatry, 2018; Gross and Levenson, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1993; Butler et al., Emotion, 2003; Jordan et al., Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2011; Chou and Edge, Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, 2012; Apryl Williams, Social Media + Society, 2020; Hadley Freeman, The Guardian, April 13, 2020; Barron et al., Computers in Human Behavior Reports, 2023; Muir et al., PLOS ONE, 2023; Yale News, September 18, 2017; Brady et al., PNAS, 2017; Joel Dinerstein, National WWII Museum, 2021; Chervonsky and Hunt, Emotion, 2017.